Garbage Disposal Replacement

It is easier to understand what is wrong with our garbage disposal when we know how it works.

Garbage Disposal CutawayHere we see a cutaway view of a standard garbage disposal. There are many types and designs of garbage disposals on the market. Your garbage disposal might not look exactly like the one in the photo but the mechanics are similar. The food enters from the top through the throat. The plate with the blades spin when turned on which grind the food. The food particles and water pass through narrow slits in the side of the chamber. Dishwasher discharge also enters the chamber via the black port on the right. If the knockout for the dishwasher has not been removed prior to installation, the dishwasher cannot discharge and may cause damage to the unit, leaking and flooding. This is why it is important to have a licensed plumber install your garbage disposal to insure safe proper installation. Garbage disposals have electric, water and metal moving parts and vibration. This is a recipe for disaster if you get the wrong installer.

"Do I Need a New Garbage Disposal?"

For the twenty six years that I've been a plumber, one of the first things that customers have asked me when servicing their garbage disposal is, "Do I need a new garbage disposal?". This is a little bit of a loaded question and usually subjective to the individual customer with a few exceptions. The simplest way to break this down is to separate the service into two categories: 1. Must replace and 2. Can replace.

Disclaimer- Electricity is dangerous and even fatal, always consult with a professional before attempting any repairs yourself!

Must replace: You must replace your garbage disposal whenever any of the following apply:

  • Garbage disposal will not turn on. The electricity has been verified to be working all the way to the aperture with the switch on. Push in the reset button on the bottom of the unit and verified it stays closed. (If you don't know what some of that means it's ok, but you should probably have a professional take a look to avoid possible injury or death by trying it yourself.)
  • Grinding metal and overload switch pop. When key is inserted into the bottom of the garbage disposal and turned, there is a grinding metallic sound even after turning several times in both directions. This indicates a failed bearing or excessive internal corrosion. A second indicator of this would be when you turn on the switch to the unit, the overload switch pops open. (Warning! Never turn on the switch to the unit with the garbage disposal key inserted into the bottom!)
  • Angry panel breaker. If the panel breaker trips when you turn on the switch for the unit, There is a dead short. This is a very dangerous condition and must be addressed immediately by a qualified professional!
  • Water Leaking. Water leaking from below the metal throat or from the bottom of the unit is a sure indicator that there's a bad seal and the unit must be replaced.

Can replace:

  • Leaking from the metal throat/up means that the throat is not sealed properly. The garbage disposal has not been locked properly in place, or the throat seal needs to be replaced. I suggest that if the throat is leaking, it's probably a good idea to go ahead and change the garbage disposal.
  • If a unit is over 5 years old and gives you any trouble at all, I suggest replacing it. In my experience garbage disposals last around 5-7 years on average. This will vary greatly depending on the quality of the local water and the types of chemical the individual uses.

Request Free Estimate

Garbage Disposal Do's and Dont's

Insinkerator, a prominent leading garbage disposal manufacturer has a simple page on what they feel is acceptable for their units. Feel free to take a peek at what they have to say on the subject by clicking on this link: http://blog.insinkerator.com/what-not-put-garbage-disposal/

Having serviced these units and those of other manufacturers for the past twenty six years, I have some pretty strong opinions on the subject. I feel that Insinkerator is quite liberal and overly optimistic on the topic of what should go into a garbage disposal. There are several factors to consider which can help you make choices which are best for your particular conditions and thereby minimize the chances of having to endure a plumber and his gross sewer machine in your newly remodeled kitchen working on your brand new tile.

Things to consider before cramming certain foods into your garbage disposal:

Galvanized SteelHow old is my house? If your house is older than the movie "Rainman" (1988), chances are you shouldn't be cramming food into your garbage disposal like its a garbage compactor. Homes that are over twenty-five years old tend to have piping which is either made of copper, galvanized steel pipe, or cast iron. Galvanized steel piping is readily identifiable by the threaded ends which are transitioned by super tight 90 degree turn which have hollow insides and narrow entrances which loooove gathering food particles. It is usually at a point of change of direction where a clog will begin and work its way back upstream like an accordian until the last hole closes with food which then compresses the whole works.


"Help is Here" with Applause Plumbing and Heating

We arrive on time, maintain a clean work area, and treat your home or business like it is our own. With over 25 years of Master Plumber experience, it is easy to see why we are consistently the best reviewed plumber in town.

Request Free Estimate